Tue Feb 13, 2018 3:47 pm
Ok ,since I know the emergency director at SONGS she is currently talking to one of the employees that did the Whelen upgrade in 2006 and ask where they put them.
But here is the story she sent me about upgrading to the Whelens ,this upgrade has been planned 2 years before the upgrade actually happened. The Model 120s are also know as SCE 120s and the FS110s are the STL-10s. It says that the Model 120s and STL-10s were installed in September of 1982.
Regulatory Evaluation for the siren upgrade project 6/10/2004
1.0. Background and Scope -
San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station (SONGS) has requested and received approval from FEMA (Ref. 6.7) to implement a change to the Offsite Community Alert Siren System. The change is to substitute the existing SCE120 and FS110 sirens with Whelen Engineering Model 2800 series sirens, which are of equivalent sound ratings. The new sirens will be placed in the same locations as the sirens that they are replacing with the exception of a few that may be moved to a different but close by location. In these instances, the movement will not reduce the acoustic coverage. These moves were requested by the jurisdiction and an evaluation determined that the acoustic coverage would not be reduced.
Additionally, a new system controller will be installed which will maintain an equivalent capability to initiate system operation and testing. Since the controller will not change testing activities or the methods for polling a siren and is not described in regulations or the Emergency Plan as having to meet any specific standard, evaluation of the new controller is not required and is not included in this 10CFR50.54(q) evaluation, (Note: the FEMA approved vendor substantiated this conclusion). Other minor changes will be made that include the addition of a board display that will provide siren operability results to personnel in the EOF and minor movement of ENS Yellow phones may occur to locate them in the siren cabinets. The purpose for moving the phone is to improve human factoring. The operability of the equipment will in no way be affected. For both of these minor changes there will be no reduction in effectiveness and further evaluation is not required.
The reason for this change is as follows:
The original sirens were installed by SCE and certified by the Federal Emergency Management Agency in 1982. There are several factors that justify the replacement of the existing sirens including obsolescence, environmental, and regulatory. The system is aging and by the year 2004 will be 22 years old. The predicted useful life of the siren system is about 20 years.
The remote monitoring components of the system began operation in 1994. The certification of full operability occurred in 1996. At the time of their replacement the remote telemetry modules will have exceeded their expected 8-year life cycle.
The following support this change:
· The physical condition of the sirens is showing wear. Proximity to the ocean is causing rusting and some components are showing signs of degradation. The SCE-built sirens are showing indications of coating and motor degradation and have failed throughout the years on a routine basis.
· There are no SCE-built 120 dB spares available.
· The Federal Signal sirens consist of 25 single-phase sirens and 3 three-phase sirens. The single-phase sirens are no longer available from the manufacturer and there are no spares available.
· The remote monitoring system control software is DOS based. The software manufacture no longer supports the software.
· The dedicated computers that run the monitoring system, display status and log history will also have reached the end of their expected useful life. In addition, the monitoring system is not compatible with the control system for the new Whelen 2800 series sirens.
· Expected reliability for the system, as defined in the NRC Performance Indicator program, is 94%. Considering the issues noted above, the percent reliability is expected to decrease by 2004, thus justifying this replacement project to continue to conform to NRC regulations for alert and notification systems.
A rapid replacement program will decrease the probability of maintenance and testing errors by having all one type of sirens versus three different types to manage.
Last edited by
Duderocks5539 on Thu Mar 22, 2018 2:05 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Proud owner of a Whelen ESC-2020 controller, Federal Thunderbolt 1000A, Federal Model L, Darley Model 2 and a Model 120 from the San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant.
Model 120 wiki:
https://wiki.airraidsirens.net/Model_120