TelcoJoe, could you ask your friend about the one on Beacon Hill? I hunted for it, and I'm determined to locate it-- you and your friend just might be the break I needed. The Seattle archive photo on the VictorySiren site shows a Chrysler on a four-legged metal tower like those at Northacres and Phinney Ridge, on a barren hillside with a diagonal road going up past it. All of that area is wooded and full of houses now, but there are many patches of forest where it could be.
VictorySiren photo here, says it's on a tower "above Rainier Ave."
http://www.antiqueweekend.com/x/photo-p ... oto-83.htm Another page on the site says the tower is above Rainier Ave., south of Columbia City.
I found an old municipal siren list, which gave its location as Andover & Letitia. At least today, Andover & Letitia don't cross directly. What's more, Andover & Letitia are NORTH of Columbia City! For the time being, though, I took "Andover & Letitia" as more likely to be accurate.
Here's a map I drew for explanation:
http://imgur.com/Ez1Tom4
In the center of the photo, running vertically, is a hill. Rainier Ave. runs in the valley to the east (right), Martin Luther King Way in the valley to its west. Andover, which is broken up, is in yellow. Letitia in turquoise. I had thought the northern end of 34th Ave. S. (in orange) might be the diagonally-uphill road in the photo, which would put the siren at the location of the blue square-- houses now stand there. I had been hunting in the green forested area. At the corner of 31st & Bradford there are trails going down into the forest where the map says "Lake People Park." I found nothing. The southern end of the park is closest to Andover & Letitia's not-intersection, has no trails, and I couldn't see anything in there, either. I'd think the brown, rusty tower would 'pop' among the green trees.
Then, I spoke with a woman I met on the street near 34th & Letitia (where orange and turquoise lines meet), who told me that she vaguely remembered "a big thing on a tower, up on the hill somewhere" years ago, but did not know, even approximately, where that was, save that she pointed generally west. Last, I went to the Columbia City offices (Chamber of Commerce? Neighborhood Association? I forget) and asked for the longest-tenured employee. He had never seen anything of the sort, but he asked a few others who had lived in the area for a while, with no luck.
I then roamed all over that little hill, hoping to see it in a back yard or something, its tower just obscured by houses and topography. But it really needed to face, or be ON, a slope, and all of the slopes here had houses. I did examine them, on both sides of the hill, without luck. There is a strong chance that Seattle, or a home-builder, cut the tower down years ago and scrapped everything.
However, what if the lists are VERY wrong? What if it is actually above MLK? At the time of installation, perhaps Rainier was THE biggest road in the area. Could it be west of where I've been looking, in the dense forested zone marked "???" Another expedition is probably in order.